Brooklyn artist Freddy's new project centers around newborns. Meanwhile, he and his boyfriend, Mo, have recruited their best friend, Polly, to have a baby with them. While grappling with the stress of an art opening and the complications of conceiving a child via artificial insemination, the three start to be harassed by The Bishop, a mentally ill neighborhood man. An escalating series of incidents threaten to derail the comfortable lives this trio have built for themselves.